Best Fall Lawn Fertilizer Reviews: Top Picks for a Lush Lawn

Fall is here, and it’s the perfect time to give your lawn the TLC it needs to stay healthy through winter and bounce back beautifully next spring. Whether you have cool-season grasses or warm-season grasses, choosing the best fall fertilizer is essential for maintaining a green, lush lawn. Let’s dive into the best picks for fall lawn fertilizers and some handy tips for applying them effectively.

Why Fertilize Your Lawn in the Fall?

Fall is the perfect time of year to give your lawn some extra love. Fertilizing in early fall can make a huge difference, setting up your grass for success in the colder months and ensuring it bursts back to life in the spring. Here’s why you should consider fertilizing your lawn in the fall:

Strengthens Roots

First things first, fertilizing in early fall is fantastic for strengthening grass roots. Early fall is the best time to apply a slow-release fertilizer that helps the roots grow deeper and stronger, preparing them for winter dormancy. Good root growth is essential because they allow your grass to absorb essential nutrients come spring, resulting in a healthier, more vibrant lawn. Plus, healthy grass roots enhance your lawn's ability to handle summer stress and heavy rain.

Boosts Nutrient Storage

Another great reason to fertilize in the fall is that it boosts your lawn’s nutrient storage. Applying fertilizer now allows your grass to store up essential nutrients over the winter. These nutrients are gradually released and absorbed by the grass, promoting rapid growth in early spring. This is especially beneficial for cool-season grasses, which thrive in the cooler temperatures of early fall. By fertilizing at this time of year, you're ensuring your lawn has a nutrient reservoir to draw from when the growing season starts again, leading to a lush, green lawn.

Improves Resilience

A well-fertilized lawn is more resilient and better equipped to handle winter stresses like heavy rain and cold temperatures. The nutrients from the fertilizer improve the grass's overall resilience, allowing it to recover quickly from winter damage. Fertilizing in early fall also helps prepare the grass for temperature fluctuations and potential summer stress in late spring and early summer. By fortifying your lawn now, you’re setting it up for a successful growing season.

Enhances Overall Lawn Health

Fall fertilization significantly enhances your lawn’s overall health by providing a balanced diet of essential nutrients, including nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. A healthy lawn is more resistant to diseases, pests, and weeds. Organic fertilizers, made from natural ingredients like bone meal, are a great choice for improving soil health and supporting microbial activity.

Encourages Thick, Green Grass

Fertilizing your lawn in the fall encourages thick, green grass by promoting strong root growth and nutrient uptake. This thick, green grass looks great and helps prevent soil erosion and provides a sturdy surface for outdoor activities. Whether you have a new lawn or an established one, fall fertilization can make a significant difference in the appearance and health of your grass.

Best Practices for Fall Fertilization

Here are some tips to make the most of your fall fertilization efforts:

Perform a Soil Test

Before you start, do a soil test to find out what specific nutrients your lawn needs. This will help you choose the best fertilizer for your type of grass and soil conditions.

Choose the Right Fertilizer

Pick a fertilizer that suits your lawn’s needs. Slow release fertilizers are perfect for fall because they provide a steady supply of nutrients over time. There are countless different grass types though, so make sure the kind of fertilizer you choose is compatible with your grass species.

Apply at the Right Time

The best time to apply fall fertilizer is in early September and then again in late October or early November. This timing ensures your lawn gets the nutrients it needs to recover from summer stress and get ready for winter stress.

Use Proper Application Techniques

Use a fertilizer spreader to ensure even distribution, and water your lawn after fertilizing to help the nutrients penetrate the soil and reach the grass roots.

Which Type of Fertilizer is Right for Your Lawn?

Choosing the right fertilizer for your lawn can feel like a big decision, but understanding the different kinds of fertilizer can really help. Whether you’re looking to support new grass growth, combat weeds, or just maintain a lush lawn, there are a few key options to consider.

Granular Fertilizers

These come in solid particles that you spread over your lawn with a fertilizer spreader. There are two main types: slow-release and quick-release. Slow-release granular fertilizers are fantastic because they provide a steady supply of nutrients over time.

Products like Andersons PGF Complete are well-known for their balanced nutrient release. On the flip side, quick-release granular fertilizers deliver nutrients rapidly, giving your lawn an immediate boost. Just remember, they might need more frequent applications to keep nutrient levels up. Granular fertilizers are easy to apply and work well for large areas, but they can be less precise than liquid fertilizers and might require watering in.

Liquid Fertilizers

These are mixed with water and applied using a garden hose attachment. They're absorbed quickly by the grass, which means the nutrients become available fast. This type is great for targeted applications and is super easy to apply with a garden hose. However, they might need more frequent applications and can end up being more expensive over time.

Organic Fertilizers 

Organic fertilizers are made from natural materials like compost, manure, or bone meal. These are great because they improve soil health by adding organic matter and supporting microbial activity. They’re environmentally friendly, improve soil structure, and are safe for pets and children. However, organic fertilizers release nutrients more slowly and can sometimes have an odor.

Synthetic Fertilizers 

Synthetic fertilizers are chemically formulated to provide specific nutrients. They have a high nutrient content and can be tailored to the exact needs of your lawn. These fertilizers act fast and can be customized for particular needs, like high nitrogen for new grass. But, be cautious as they can potentially lead to nutrient runoff and might harm soil health over time.

Starter Fertilizers 

Starter fertilizers are designed specifically for new lawns or freshly sown grass seeds, usually having higher phosphorus content to promote root development. They’re perfect for new lawns but not necessary for established ones.

For specialized needs, there are options like weed and feed fertilizers, which combine fertilizer with weed killers. These are convenient as they feed the grass while also acting as a weed preventer. Just ensure they're suitable for your type of grass and watch out for potential chemical runoff.

What is the NPK Ratio Found on Fertilizers?

The NPK ratio is a set of three numbers found on fertilizer packages that indicate the relative proportions of three essential nutrients: nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K). This ratio is crucial for understanding what benefits a particular fertilizer will provide for your lawn or garden.

  1. Nitrogen (N): The first number in the NPK ratio represents nitrogen. Nitrogen is essential for promoting lush, green growth and helps with the formation of chlorophyll. It's especially important for leaf development. If your lawn looks yellow or stunted, it might need more nitrogen.

  2. Phosphorus (P): The second number indicates the amount of phosphorus. Phosphorus is crucial for root development and flower and fruit production. It helps plants convert other nutrients into usable building blocks with which to grow. This nutrient is especially important for establishing new grass or plants.

  3. Potassium (K): The third number represents potassium. Potassium helps plants resist disease, enhances drought tolerance, and improves overall plant health. It aids in the movement of water and nutrients in the plant and strengthens cell walls.

For example, a fertilizer with an NPK ratio of 10-10-10 contains 10% each of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. Depending on your soil test results and the specific needs of your lawn or garden, you might choose a fertilizer with a different NPK ratio to target the areas that need the most help.

Understanding the NPK ratio helps you choose the right fertilizer for your specific lawn care needs, ensuring that your grass and plants receive the proper nutrients for optimal growth and health.

Best Lawn Fertilizer Options to Use This Fall

Best Overall: Milorganite Slow-Release Nitrogen Fertilizer

Features:

  • Type: Slow-release organic fertilizer

  • NPK Ratio: 6-4-0

  • Coverage: 2,500 square feet per bag

  • Benefits: Provides a steady release of nutrients, improves soil health, and supports strong root growth.

Pros:

  • Made from natural materials, safe for children and pets.

  • Encourages microbial activity in the soil.

  • Helps grass retain a vibrant green color through the winter.

Cons:

  • Takes longer to show results compared to synthetic fertilizers.

Average Price:

$12-$15 per bag

Best for Cool Season Grass: Scotts Turf Builder WinterGuard Fall Lawn Food

Features:

  • Type: Granular fertilizer

  • NPK Ratio: 32-0-10

  • Coverage: 5,000 square feet per bag

  • Benefits: Strengthens roots, improves water absorption, and prepares grass for the winter.

Pros:

  • High nitrogen content promotes healthy blade growth.

  • Ideal for early fall application to combat summer stress.

Cons:

  • Not suitable for warm-season grasses.

Average Price:

$20-$25 per bag

Best Organic Fertilizer: Espoma Organic Fall Fertilizer

Features:

  • Type: Organic granular fertilizer

  • NPK Ratio: 8-0-5

  • Coverage: 5,000 square feet per bag

  • Benefits: Made from natural ingredients, enhances soil health, and supports a balanced diet for your lawn.

Pros:

  • Safe for the environment and beneficial for soil organic matter levels.

  • Promotes strong roots and healthy lawns.

Cons:

  • Lower nutrient content compared to synthetic fertilizers.

Average Price:

$25-$30 per bag

Best for Warm-Season Grasses: Pennington Ultragreen Lawn Fertilizer

Features:

  • Type: Granular fertilizer

  • NPK Ratio: 30-0-4

  • Coverage: 5,000 square feet per bag

  • Benefits: Promotes strong roots, enhances color, and prepares grass for winter dormancy.

Pros:

  • High nitrogen content for vigorous growth.

  • Suitable for both warm-season and cool-season grasses.

Cons:

  • May require additional weed control products for complete lawn care.

Average Price:

$25-$30 per bag

Best Budget Option: GreenView Fall Lawn Food

Features:

  • Type: Granular fertilizer

  • NPK Ratio: 22-0-10

  • Coverage: 5,000 square feet per bag

  • Benefits: Provides essential nutrients at an affordable price, promotes strong roots and healthy grass.

Pros:

  • Cost-effective and easy to apply.

  • Supports lawn fertilization during the critical fall period.

Cons:

  • Lower nutrient content may require more frequent applications.

Average Price:

$15-$20 per bag

How to Apply Fall Lawn Fertilizer

Timing

  • Early Fall: Apply the first round of fertilizer in early September to help the lawn recover from the long hot summer months.

  • Late Fall: A late fall application in late October or early November ensures nutrients are stored for the winter.

Method

  • Spreader Type: Use a fertilizer spreader for even distribution. Drop spreaders are great for precise applications, while broadcast spreaders cover larger areas quickly.

  • Watering: Water your lawn after fertilizing to help the nutrients penetrate the soil and reach the grass roots.

Expert Tips for Fall Lawn Care

Aerate Your Lawn

Aerating your lawn before fertilizing improves soil aeration, allowing the nutrients to reach the roots more effectively. This is especially important if your soil is compacted.

Mow Regularly

Keep your lawn mowed to a height of about 2.5 to 3 inches. This ensures even nutrient distribution and reduces the risk of fungal diseases.

Remove Leaves and Debris

Clear fallen leaves and debris from your lawn to prevent them from blocking sunlight and trapping moisture. This helps maintain a healthy lawn and reduces the risk of disease.

Benefits of Fall Fertilizing

Stronger Roots

Fall fertilizing helps grass develop strong roots that can absorb nutrients more effectively. This prepares the lawn for the stresses of winter and promotes rapid growth in the spring.

Improved Color and Density

Applying fertilizer in the fall enhances the color and density of your lawn, giving it a vibrant green appearance. This makes your lawn look healthy and well-maintained throughout the year.

Better Disease Resistance

A well-fertilized lawn is more resistant to diseases and pests. The nutrients provided by the fertilizer help the grass develop a stronger immune system, reducing the risk of fungal infections and other issues.

Common Questions About Fall Lawn Fertilizing

Where Can I Buy Fall Fertilizer? 

You can snag fall lawn fertilizer from several convenient spots. Home Depot is a great option with a variety of granular, liquid, and organic fertilizers. Big box stores like Lowe’s and Walmart also stock plenty of lawn care products. Don’t forget your local garden centers for specialty items and expert advice. 

When is the Best Time to Apply Fall Fertilizer?

A good time to apply fall fertilizer is in early September. It's also a good idea to use a second application in late October or early November. This ensures your lawn receives the nutrients it needs to recover from summer stress and prepare for winter dormancy.

How Much Fertilizer Should I Use?

The amount of fertilizer to use depends on the size of your lawn and the specific product you choose. According to general guidelines, apply 1 pound of nitrogen per 1,000 square feet of lawn. Always follow the manufacturer's recommendations for the best results.

Can I Use Organic Fertilizer in the Fall?

Yes, organic fertilizers are a great choice for fall fertilizing. They provide essential nutrients while improving soil health and promoting microbial activity. Look for products made from natural materials like bone meal and compost.

What is the Best Fertilizer for Cool-Season Grasses?

For cool-season grasses, a fertilizer with a high nitrogen content and slow-release formula is ideal. Scotts Turf Builder WinterGuard Fall Lawn Food is a great option, as it provides the nutrients needed for healthy growth and strong roots.

Can I Apply Weed Control Products in the Fall?

While some people apply weed control products in the fall, it's generally best to focus on fertilizing unless there are signs of trouble. Fall is a critical time for root development, and weed control products can sometimes interfere with this process.

How Do I Know if My Lawn Needs Fertilizing?

Signs that your lawn needs fertilizing include yellowing grass, thin or patchy areas, and slow growth. A soil test can also help determine if your lawn is lacking essential nutrients.

Final Thoughts

Fall fertilizing is a crucial step in maintaining healthy, vibrant, and lush lawns. By choosing the best fall lawn fertilizer and following expert tips for application, you can ensure your grass stays strong and green throughout the winter and into the spring. Whether you prefer organic options or traditional granular fertilizers, there's a product out there to meet your needs. Invest in your lawn this fall and enjoy a lush, green landscape next year.

 
 

You might also like…

Hi, I’m Jen!

Hi, I’m Jen, your perpetually optimistic, fun-loving, witty friend. When I’m not working at The Marketing Greenhouse, you can find me gardening in the sun, playing games with my kids or creating content that inspires people to try new things and be the best version of themselves.


 
 

Trending Posts

Previous
Previous

Kitchen Remodel Ideas on a Budget: Greige Cabinets Makeover

Next
Next

How to Order a Keto Pumpkin Spice Latte at Starbucks this Fall